Thanksgiving is a special time to gather with your loved ones and enjoy a delicious meal. And this annual feast wouldn’t be complete without dessert, featuring a couple of delicious pies, of course!
Pies are the perfect way to end a Thanksgiving meal, and if you’re ready to make your own this year, we want to help. We’ve gathered over 30 recipes from the best food bloggers on the Internet for you to choose from.
If you’re searching for some of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes to impress your friends and family with your pie-making skills, this is the right place.
These recipes are carefully selected to help you create the ultimate dessert spread, with options that caters to different preferences and dietary needs. So, roll up your sleeves, and let’s dive into making this Thanksgiving unforgettable with these irresistible pie recipes.
Please note that if you’d rather not bake this year, we’ve also got a list of the Best Pie Shops in Los Angeles, any of which would be happy to do the work for you.
35 Delicious Pie Recipes To Complete Your Holiday Meal Your Family Will Thank You For
Best Easy Pumpkin Pie
From Joyous Apron
With a million and one things to do around the holidays, who needs one more complicated thing on their list? If you want to make pumpkin pie for dessert, this simple recipe looks like a winner.
The Best Gluten-Free Vegan Pumpkin Pie (Allergy-Free)
From Strength & Sunshine
When you need a healthy version of pumpkin pie that’s allergy-free but still delicious, give this recipe a try. We think it looks positively amazing!
Gluten-Free Crustless Sweet Potato Pie (Vegan, Allergy-Free, Paleo)
From Strength & Sunshine
Do you prefer a sweet potato pie rather than pumpkin — or any other flavor — for Thanksgiving? If so, this recipe looks like the perfect replacement. As a bonus, it’s gluten-free, Vegan, Paleo, and allergy-free.
Mini Chocolate Pecan Pies
From Waiting for Blancmange
If you love pecan pie, this mini version of chocolate pecan pie is sure to please. These bite-size morsels look so tempting we dare you to try and eat just one!
Indiana Sugar Cream Pie (Hoosier Pie)
From The Short Order Cook
This dessert is the state pie of Indiana and boasts of a custard-type filling that contains neither fruits nor vegetables. Although it was created out of the desperation of the depression, it stuck around because of its delicious, creamy taste.
Brown Sugar Caramel Apple Pie
From The Short Order Cook
While it may not sound possible, this pie is essentially filled with caramel apples. It may just be the perfect pie for fall and your Thanksgiving table.
Related: Best Restaurants in Los Angeles for Thanksgiving Take-out
Best Apple Pie Recipe (My Favorite British Apple Pie)
From Christina’s Cucina
Once you follow the instructions found in this apple pie recipe, and taste the results, we believe you’ll see that not all apple pie recipes are the same. This one calls for no cinnamon.
Oatmeal Pie
From Little Sunny Kitchen
Have you every heard of oatmeal pie? If you can’t have nuts, this pie is a great substitute for the more well known pecan pie many people serve for Thanksgiving.
Carrot Pie
From Little Sunny Kitchen
Although this pie looks a lot like it’s made from pumpkins, it actually contains carrots. Who knows? Once you family tries it, this smooth, sweet pie might become a famorite dessert for fall gatherings and holidays.
Pumpkin Pecan Pie
From Little Sunny Kitchen
Why settle for a single pie that’s either pecan or pumpkin when you can combine the two into one delicious after dinner treat? While there are several ingredients and steps to make this pie, we think the results will be worth it.
No-Bake Nutella Cheesecake with Oreo Crust
From Saving Talents
If you’re searching for a pie recipe that’s a snap to make and doesn’t require any baking, this one fits the bill. And who doesn’t love delicious Nutella and Oreos?
Related: Run a Turkey Trot in SoCal (so you can eat more pie)
No-Bake Pumpkin Mousse Pie (Perfect for Fall)
From She’s Not Cookin’
This pie is the perfect end to most fall get-togethers, including week-night meals and holiday events. It’s a cinch to make, incorporates all the yummy flavors of fall, and can be made in advance.
Purple Sweet Potato Pie with Torched Meringue
From The Sage Apron
Do you want to serve a showstopping dessert at your next holiday meal that’s as pretty as it is delicious? This purple sweet potato pie recipe might be just what you’re looking for.
Pecan Cream Pie
From Together as Family
When you like pecans but don’t really like traditional pecan pie (it happens!), you might want to consider giving this recipe a try. Just choose your pie crust and follow the directions to make this light, yummy looking pie.
Old Fashioned Baked Peanut Butter Pie
From Cooking with Carlee
Can you imagine anything more delightfull than a piece of hot, ooey, peanut buttery pie? Perhaps with a scoop of chocolate icecream? Yum!
Cranberry Apple Pie
From If You Give a Blonde a Kitchen
Make your tastebuds happy, as well as your stomach, by sinking your teeth into a bite of this cranberry apple pie. It’s just the right combination of tart and sweet for your Thanksgiving feast.
Related: Find Fun Things To Do with Kids Thanksgiving Week (besides baking pies)
Gluten-Free Crustless Apple Pie (Vegan, Allergy-Free)
From Strength & Sunshine
If you, or someone in your family, has a gluten intollerance, give this gluten-free apple pie a try this holiday season. It’s sure to please — and there’s no crust, which is a winner for those who don’t enjoy it.
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie
From Three Olives Branch
When you’re looking for a holiday pie that’s a little different than most of the traditional pies served at Thanksgiving, this one’s for you. It has rich chocolate plus nuts and a hint of bourbon flavor.
Best Cannoli Pie Recipe
From Ugly Duckling Bakery
Cannoli in the form of a pie anyone? We think, yes please! Doesn’t it just look divine with all of that rich chocolate and cream?
Apple and Blackberry Pie
From Ugly Duckling Bakery
Why choose just one fruit to put in your next pie when you could combine two and make it doubly delicious? Check out this apple and blackberry pie recipe and make one for your Thanksgiving meal.
Simple Caramel Cream Pie (no bake)
From Sweet Fix Baker
Smooth, rich caramel fills the crust of this pie. Add a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkling of chocolate chips or a drizzle of cholocolate and it will be gobbled up by everyone this Thanksgiving.
Pear & Salted Caramel Pie
From Sweet Fix Baker
We’d be surprised to find out that any of this pie was left once you place it on your table after the main course is finished. The salty yet sweet filling may just make it hard to resist having a second slice!
Keto Pecan Pie – Only 4g net carbs
From Low Carb Spark
Just because you’re eating Keto it doesn’t mean you have to skip dessert — at least not with this recipe! It’s full of rich, delicious pecans and gooey, yummy flavor.
Blackberry Tart with Chocolate and Mascarpone
From Oh My Veg
Fruit pies and tarts, like this blackberry tart, are the perfect complement to a Thanksgiving turkey with all of the traditional fixings and sides. And this luscious looking tart will also be a pretty addition to your table.
Chocolate Nut Tart {Tarta De Tres Nueces}
From What a Girl Eats
This recipe might not be for a traditional pie like you might expect after a big Thanksgiving meal, but we think a small piece might top the meal off perfectly with a cup of coffee.
Cranberry Meringue Pie
From The Simple Sweet Life
Instead of, or in addition to, serving cranberry sauce during your holiday meal this Thanksgiving, why not also serve it in the form of a pie?
No Bake Keto Peanut Butter Pie
From Low Carb Spark
We think this pie looks like it’s not only easy to make, but also a delicious way to end your Thanksgiving meal. And we bet your family will agree!
The Best Shoofly Pie
From Platter Talk
Shoofly pie is a dessert that has been made for many years in certain parts of the country. The richness comes from molasses and brown sugar, but we’d gamble your family and friends will love it.
Amaretto Cream Pie with Almond Crust
From XOXOBella
Rich, creamy pies are the perfect way to end just about any meal, including your Thanksgiving or Friendsgiving meal. And we dare you to pass on this pie without eating a slice!
Vegan Banoffee Pie
From Baked by Clo
Although this pie may resembe a tart, we think it still looks like an amazing dessert choice for Thanksgiving. Plus, it’s Vegan and you don’t need to turn on your oven to make it.
Apple Blueberry Pie
From The Littlest Crumb
While fall harvest provides an abundance of fruit, you may not always know what to do with it all. But why not put those apples and berries into a pie for Thanksgiving?
Cranberry Curd Tart
From Casual Foodist
This beautiful pie will look amazing on your table this Thanksgiving, and we’ll bet it will taste good too. What’s more, you’ll impress your guests with it!
Harvest Almond and Apple Pie
From Delicious on a Dime
You can make this harvest almond and apple pie with very little effort following this recipe. And we predict that your family and friends will thank you for making it after they sink their teeth into it!
Cranberry Pie
From This Wife Cooks
This pie has a crumble topping and looks pretty enough to adorn any Holiday table this year. However, we think it will be tart and delicious too!
Easy Crustless Nantucket Cranberry Pie
From What a Girl Eats
You won’t have to make a crust with this simple pie recipe. And the tart yet sweet cranberries are the perfect way to finish your Thanksgiving meal.
Jeanne Sloan is a farm wife, mother of two, and grandmother of two who was born in Las Vegas, Nevada but was transformed into a country girl at the age of eight when her parents moved the family to Kansas. You can read more from Jeanne Sloan at mid-lifemusings.com where she writes about whatever strikes her fancy, including advice, recipes, and more.
Acknowledgment: This round-up of recipes and photos from other bloggers was made with their full and express permission to share. We’re grateful to them for sharing their creativity and talent and we encourage you to visit each of their websites for many more recipes like these.
